Culinary Explorer

A cooking platform built around craft, culture, and the stories behind what we eat.

Free with an account.

Vermont Apple Pie with Cheddar Crust

Vermont Apple Pie with Cheddar Crust

Created by Chef Dean

The quintessential New England marriage of sweet and savory: layers of tart apples spiced with cinnamon and nutmeg, encased in a shatteringly flaky crust laced with sharp Vermont cheddar that melts into golden, savory pockets.

Pastries & Cookies
American
Thanksgiving, Holiday, Comfort Food
45 min
Prep Time
1 hr cook•3 hr total
YieldOne 9-inch double-crust pie (8 servings)

There is a saying in New England that has survived nearly two centuries: 'Apple pie without the cheese is like a kiss without the squeeze.' This is not mere folklore. It is culinary wisdom passed down from Yankee farmwives who understood something profound about the way sharp cheddar and tart apples speak to each other.

The tradition likely arrived with English settlers who served their fruit pies with wedges of aged cheese, a practice dating back to medieval times when cheese was eaten with most everything sweet. Vermont took ownership of the pairing when its dairy farms began producing cheddar of such character that it demanded inclusion in the crust itself. By the 1800s, county fairs across New England were awarding blue ribbons to pies that folded sharp cheese directly into the pastry.

The technique is straightforward but unforgiving. Your cheddar must be cold, your butter colder still, and your touch light enough that the fats stay in distinct pieces rather than melting into the flour. Those pieces create the layers. They create the shatter. Get this right and you will produce a crust that breaks apart in buttery, cheesy flakes. Get it wrong and you have a tough, homogeneous shell unworthy of the apples inside.

I have baked this pie for Thanksgiving tables from Portland to Burlington. The response is always the same: first skepticism, then a single bite, then a request for seconds. The cheese doesn't overwhelm. It provides a savory counterpoint that makes the apples taste more like themselves.

Ingredients

all-purpose flour (for crust)

Quantity

2 1/2 cups (315g)

granulated sugar (for crust)

Quantity

1 tablespoon

fine sea salt (for crust)

Quantity

1 teaspoon

The rest of this recipe is free with an account.

You have reached the limit for recipes without an account. Create a free account to keep reading.

By signing in, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in