A cooking platform built around craft, culture, and the stories behind what we eat.
Created by
The golden, clear beef broth that opens every proper Austrian meal, simmered for three quiet hours from marrow bones and Suppengrün until it becomes the foundation that dozens of Einlagen call home.
Gretel always said you can judge a cook by their broth. Not by their pastry, not by their Schnitzel. By their broth. She'd hold a spoonful up to the light in my grandmother Eva's kitchen in Kent, checking the color, the clarity, whether it had that deep amber glow that means the bones gave up everything they had to give. Phony soup came from a cube. Real soup came from time.
Klare Rindssuppe is the soup that every Austrian meal is supposed to begin with, and in the best kitchens, it still does. It's not consommé in the French sense, clarified with egg whites into something almost clinical. Viennese broth keeps its warmth. It's clear but not sterile, golden but not dark, and it carries the taste of good beef and root vegetables in every spoonful. The clarity comes from patience: cold water, slow heat, careful skimming. No tricks. No shortcuts that actually work.
What makes Austrian broth culture extraordinary is what happens after the broth is made. The Viennese developed dozens of Einlagen, soup garnishes that turn a single clear broth into a different dish every night of the week. Frittaten, Leberknödel, Griesnockerl, Backerbsen, Nudeln, Milzschnitten. I grew up watching Gretel and Eva debate which Einlage suited which day, as if the choice carried real weight. It did. The broth is the stage. The Einlage is the performance. But without a good stage, no performance can save you.
Make this on a Sunday when you have nowhere to be. The preparation takes thirty minutes. The simmering takes three hours and asks almost nothing of you. Your kitchen will smell like something worth coming home to.
The tradition of Klare Rindssuppe as the opening course of a formal Austrian meal dates to the Bürgerliche Küche (bourgeois kitchen) of the 19th century, when a multi-course Sunday lunch always began with a clear broth and its chosen Einlage. The Viennese system of soup garnishes, with its dozens of named variations from Frittaten to Leberknödel to Griesnockerl, is unmatched in European cooking. Gretel Beer documented more than thirty distinct Einlagen in her work, each with specific regional loyalties. The broth itself reflects Vienna's position at the crossroads of the Habsburg empire: the root vegetables echo Central European traditions, the allspice traces Ottoman trade routes, and the insistence on beef rather than chicken sets it apart from the broths of France and Italy.
Quantity
1.5 kg
cut into pieces
Quantity
500g
in one piece
Quantity
300g
Quantity
4 liters
Quantity
2 medium
peeled and halved lengthwise
Quantity
1 large
peeled and halved lengthwise
Quantity
1/4 (about 150g)
peeled and quartered
Quantity
1 medium
halved crosswise and charred cut-side down
Quantity
1 small
cleaned and halved lengthwise
Quantity
1 small bunch
Quantity
2
Quantity
8
Quantity
4
Quantity
1 tablespoon
Quantity
1 small piece
Quantity
for serving
finely cut
| Ingredient | Quantity |
|---|---|
| beef marrow bonescut into pieces | 1.5 kg |
| Tafelspitz (top round) or beef shinin one piece | 500g |
| beef scraps or short ribs (optional) | 300g |
| cold water | 4 liters |
| carrotspeeled and halved lengthwise | 2 medium |
| parsnippeeled and halved lengthwise | 1 large |
| celeriacpeeled and quartered | 1/4 (about 150g) |
| yellow onionhalved crosswise and charred cut-side down | 1 medium |
| leekcleaned and halved lengthwise | 1 small |
| fresh parsley with stems | 1 small bunch |
| bay leaves | 2 |
| whole black peppercorns | 8 |
| whole allspice berries | 4 |
| coarse salt | 1 tablespoon |
| lovage (Liebstöckel) (optional) | 1 small piece |
| fresh chivesfinely cut | for serving |
Place the marrow bones and beef in your largest pot. Cover with four liters of cold water. This must be cold. Starting with cold water pulls the proteins out of the bones gradually, which means they coagulate slowly and rise to the surface as foam you can skim away. Hot water shocks them into the broth and you end up with cloudy, murky liquid that no amount of straining will fix. Set the pot over medium heat and bring it to a slow simmer. Do not rush this. It should take a good twenty to twenty-five minutes to reach a simmer.
As the water heats, gray-brown foam will begin to gather on the surface. Skim it off with a ladle or a wide spoon, gently, without stirring the liquid underneath. Keep skimming as new foam appears. This takes about fifteen to twenty minutes and it is the step most people skip because it feels tedious. Don't skip it. Every bit of scum you remove now is clarity you'll see later. When the foam turns from gray to pale white, you've done enough. The broth beneath should already look promising.
While you skim, char the onion halves. Place them cut-side down directly on a gas flame, under a hot grill, or in a dry cast iron pan over high heat. Let them blacken until the surface is deeply caramelized, almost burnt. This looks extreme but it's doing two things for your broth: the Maillard reaction on the onion surface gives the liquid its deep golden color, and the slight bitterness from the char balances the sweetness of the root vegetables. Without it, your broth will be pale and one-dimensional.
Once the broth is skimmed clean, add the carrots, parsnip, celeriac, charred onion, leek, parsley, bay leaves, peppercorns, allspice, salt, and lovage if you have it. These root vegetables are what Austrians call Suppengrün, the soup greens, and they form the aromatic backbone of every serious Austrian broth. Don't chop them small. Large pieces give up their flavor slowly and are easier to strain out later. Reduce the heat until the surface barely trembles. You want to see a lazy bubble rise every few seconds, nothing more.
Let the broth simmer, uncovered, for two and a half to three hours. The surface should never boil. If you see rolling bubbles, your heat is too high and the fat will emulsify into the liquid, making it cloudy. Turn the flame down until the pot looks almost still. Check it now and then, not to stir (never stir a clear broth), but to make sure the simmer hasn't crept up on you. The kitchen will fill with a smell that is unmistakably Sunday. About halfway through, taste the broth. It will be thin and a little flat. By the time three hours have passed, it will be something else entirely: rich, golden, deep, the kind of broth that makes you close your eyes.
Set a fine-mesh sieve over a large clean pot and line it with a double layer of muslin or cheesecloth, dampened first so it clings to the sieve. Ladle the broth through carefully. Don't pour it, and don't press down on the vegetables. Pressing squeezes out cloudy particles. Let gravity do the work. The strained broth should be clear enough that you can see the bottom of the pot through it. If it's not, strain it once more through fresh muslin.
Taste the strained broth and adjust the salt. It should taste clean, beefy, and full, with no single flavor shouting over the others. If you're serving it today, let it sit for five minutes off the heat, then skim the fat from the surface with a spoon. A very thin film of golden fat is traditional and adds richness, but you don't want pools of it floating in the bowl. If you're making this ahead, refrigerate it overnight and peel off the solidified fat cap in the morning.
Reheat the broth gently. Ladle it into warm soup plates. Scatter finely cut chives over the surface. This is your Klare Rindssuppe in its purest form, and it is beautiful on its own. But it's also the foundation for every Austrian soup garnish: Frittaten (sliced pancake strips), Leberknödel (liver dumplings), Griesnockerl (semolina dumplings), Backerbsen (tiny fried dough puffs), or simply a handful of fine egg noodles. The Einlage you choose is the second decision. The first decision, making this broth properly, is the one that matters. Mahlzeit!
1 serving (about 310g)
Culinary guides, cultural storytelling, and the editorial depth that makes cooking meaningful.
Discover Culinary Explorer
Chef Elsa
Vienna's grandest soup bowl, golden beef broth ladled over sliced boiled beef, tender root vegetables, silky Frittaten, and pillowy Griesnockerl, the kind of first course that makes the rest of dinner nervous.
Chef Elsa
Golden fried batter pearls dropped into clear, honest Rindssuppe, where they bob on the surface before slowly drinking up the broth. The soup that Austrian children ask for by name.
Chef Elsa
Impossibly light butter dumplings floating in clear golden Rindssuppe, the kind of Suppeneinlage that separates a good Austrian kitchen from a great one.
Chef Elsa
Flour browned slowly in lard until it smells like toasted hazelnuts, thinned with good broth, warmed with caraway. The soup Austrian grandmothers made when the cupboard was nearly bare and the family still needed feeding.