Culinary Explorer

A cooking platform built around craft, culture, and the stories behind what we eat.

Free with an account.

Classic Southern Pimento Cheese

Classic Southern Pimento Cheese

Created by Chef Remy

Hand-grated sharp cheddar folded with Duke's mayonnaise, sweet jarred pimentos, and just enough cayenne to wake things up, this is the spread that built a thousand church potlucks and tailgate traditions across the South.

Appetizers & Snacks
Southern
Potluck
Picnic
Make Ahead
20 min
Prep Time
0 min cook•20 min total
YieldAbout 3 cups

There's a reason Southerners call this the caviar of the South. Not because it's fancy. Because it's irreplaceable. You can serve foie gras at a party and people will nod politely. Put out a bowl of good pimento cheese with some Ritz crackers and watch grown adults elbow each other out of the way.

The secret lives in the cheese itself. You grate it by hand. I know the bag of pre-shredded looks tempting sitting there in the dairy case, but those manufacturers coat every strand with cellulose and potato starch to keep it from clumping. That coating creates a grainy, dry spread that never comes together right. Hand-grated cheese melts into the mayonnaise, becomes one with it. That's the texture you're chasing.

Now, I've eaten pimento cheese from Virginia to Texas, and everybody's grandmother made the best version. Mine included. My grandmother Evangeline would add a splash of pickle juice from her bread and butter jar. Said it brightened everything up. She wasn't wrong. At Lagniappe, we serve ours with house-made crackers and a drizzle of pepper jelly, but the spread itself stays traditional. Some things don't need improving.

Ingredients

sharp cheddar cheese

Quantity

8 ounces

hand-grated

extra-sharp cheddar cheese

Quantity

4 ounces

hand-grated

cream cheese

Quantity

4 ounces

softened to room temperature

The rest of this recipe is free with an account.

You have reached the limit for recipes without an account. Create a free account to keep reading.

By signing in, you agree to our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account? Log in